Effective Performance Measurement: Using Personality Traits or G?

Effective Performance Measurement: Using Personality Traits or G?

Effective performance measurement is a critical aspect of organizational management, and it involves assessing employees’ performance based on various factors such as productivity, efficiency, and quality of work. Performance measurement can be done through various methods, such as self-evaluation, peer evaluation, and manager evaluation. In this paper, we will discuss performance measurement and predictors of job performance, focusing on the comparison between G and personality traits.

Predictors of Job Performance

Predictors of job performance are attributes that can be used to predict an individual’s success in a particular job. Some of the most commonly used predictors of job performance include cognitive ability, personality traits, motivation, and work experience.

Cognitive ability, also known as general mental ability or G, is one of the most reliable predictors of job performance. It refers to an individual’s overall intellectual capacity, including their ability to learn, reason, solve problems, and think critically. Cognitive ability has been found to be positively associated with job performance across a wide range of jobs, including managerial, professional, and technical jobs.

Personality traits, on the other hand, refer to an individual’s enduring patterns of thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. Some of the most commonly measured personality traits include extraversion, conscientiousness, openness to experience, agreeableness, and emotional stability. Research has shown that certain personality traits are also predictive of job performance, with conscientiousness being the most consistently related to job performance across a wide range of jobs.

Cross-Comparative Research on G and Personality for Predicting Job Performance

Numerous studies have investigated the relative importance of cognitive ability and personality traits in predicting job performance, with some studies suggesting that G is a better predictor of job performance than personality traits, while others suggest that the opposite is true.

One of the most comprehensive studies on this topic was conducted by Hunter and colleagues (2010), who analyzed data from over 200 studies and found that cognitive ability (G) was the most consistent and strongest predictor of job performance across different jobs and industries. They also found that personality traits, particularly conscientiousness, were also predictive of job performance but to a lesser extent than G.

Another study conducted by Tett and colleagues (2012) found that personality traits were better predictors of job performance than cognitive ability in jobs that required interpersonal skills, such as sales and customer service. In contrast, cognitive ability was a better predictor of job performance in jobs that required analytical skills, such as engineering and information technology.

Implications for Employers

The findings of cross-comparative research examining the differences between using G and personality for predicting subsequent job performance can have significant implications for employers.

Employers can use these findings to inform their hiring processes by considering both cognitive ability and personality traits when selecting candidates. For jobs that require analytical skills, cognitive ability may be a more critical predictor of job performance. For jobs that require interpersonal skills, personality traits, particularly conscientiousness, may be a better predictor of job performance.

Moreover, employers can also use these findings to design targeted training and development programs to enhance employees’ performance. For example, if cognitive ability is a critical predictor of job performance in a particular job, employers can provide training programs that focus on developing employees’ analytical skills.

Effective performance measurement is crucial for organizational success. By considering both cognitive ability and personality traits when selecting candidates and designing training and development programs, employers can improve their hiring processes and enhance employees’ performance.


Our dissertation experts can help you complete such an assignment, 100% original and plagiarism free. Please chat us or click this ORDER BUTTON to place your order/ get a quote on Literature Review Resources RES-850 Assignment.